TaiLexi AI日本の判例・法令
← ホーム
知財高裁

知財高判 平成19年11月22日

平成18年(行ケ)第10303号 特許取消決定取消請求事件

この判例について AI に質問

裁判所
知的財産高等裁判所
裁判年月日
平成19年11月22日 (2007-11-22)
事件番号
平成18年(行ケ)第10303号
事件名
特許取消決定取消請求事件
裁判の種類・結果
判例集等
—
分野
行政・知的財産・特許権・行政訴訟

AI 要約AI

事案の概要

  • 原告は、優先権主張を伴う特許出願(以下「本件出願」)をし、拒絶査定を受けた。
  • 本件出願は、血管内留置用ステントに薬剤を含有させた医療用具に関する発明である。
  • 拒絶査定に対する不服審判請求が成り立たないとされたため、原告が審決の取消しを求めた。
  • 審決は、本件出願の明細書の記載が優先権主張の基礎となる先の出願の明細書等に記載した事項の範囲内にないと判断した。
事案の概要・争点・判断などを表示

争点

  • 本件出願の明細書の記載が、優先権主張の基礎となる先の出願の明細書等に記載した事項の範囲内にあるか否か。

結論

  • 原告の請求を棄却する。
  • 訴訟費用は原告の負担とする。

AI が本文から作成した要約です。引用の際は本文をご確認ください。

D,L

EVA

D,L

EVA

a

b

c

d

e

f

poly-1-lactic acid/Polyglycolic acid polyanhydride

a f a f

a d

e

a d

g body passageway duct

expandable intraluminal graft

expandable vascular graft

h

g h

i The tetracyclines can be administered alone or in combination with, either before,

simultaneously, or subsequently to treatment using conventional chemotherapeutic or radiation therapy.A preferred embodiment is the systemic administration, either by injection or implantation of polymericencapsulated drug, of minocycline in combination with a chemotherapeutic such as - cyclodextrin, in

a ratio of between 0.5 and 2.0 to 1, -cyclodextrin to minocycline.Other chemotherapeutics includecarmustine BCNU , 5-fluorouracil, - cyclodextrin, vinca allcaloids such as vincristin, taxol andvinblastin, immunotoxins

Pharmaceutical compositions are prepared using the antibiotic as the active agent to inhibitangiogenesis based on the specific application. Application is either topical, localized, or systemic. Anyof these compositions may also include preservatives, antioxidants, antibiotics, immunosuppressants,and other biologically or pharmaceutically effective agents which do not exert a detrimental effect onthe antibiotic or cells. For treatment of tumors, the composition may include a cytotoxic agent whichselectively kills the faster replicating tumor cells, many of which areknown and clinically in use.

j In a preferred form, the composition is administered in combination with a biocompatiblepolymeric implant which releases the antibiotic over a controlled period of time at a selected site.Examples of preferred biodegradable polymeric materials include polyanhydrides, polyorthoesters,polyglycolic acid, polylactic acid, polyethylene vinyl acetate, and copolymers and blends thereof.Examples of preferred non-biodegradable polymeric materials include ethylene vinyl acetatecopolymers.

i j

k Drugs that prevent or reduce the proliferation of pathological cell types are essential to thetreatment and control of various diseases involving undesirable or uncontrolled cell proliferation. Butantiproliferatives, by definition, must be toxic to certain cell types. It is often not feasible to administerthese drugs systemically, because the amounts needed to control the diseased cell types may be toxic ordeadly to the patient's normal cells. This difficulty could be circumvented by administeringantiproliferative agents directly to the site of the undesired cell proliferation. A mechanism is alsoneeded for retaining antiproliferative agents at the disease site, so that they may effectively control theproliferation of undesired cells, while being restrained from migrating and damaging normal cell types.Specific diseases and conditions for which site-specific delivery and retention of antiproliferativeswould be particularly effective are briefly described below. Each of these conditions involves theproliferation of a particular undesirable cell type, and systemic administration of drug therapy for theirtreatment has not yielded optimal results.

1. Post-Angioplasty Reocclusion and Restenosis

2. Rheumatoid Arthritis

3. Ovarian Cancer

4. Psoriasis

l In accordance with the present invention, the above-described compounds are used forsiteselective delivery of therapeutic agents, and retention thereof at the selected site. According to apreferred aspect of the invention, the therapeutic agent has an anti-proliferative action, useful for thetreatment of diseases or other pathological conditions involving cell proliferation.

Such chemotherapeutic substances may be selected, for example, from the group consisting ofcolchicine, vinca alkaloids, taxol and derivatives thereof, which exhibit their bio-effect only uponrelease from the compounds.

k l 1 2

1 2

2 1

m

n

o

m o

p Abstract

A mechanical support or stent containing pharmaceutical agents. The stent can be placed in the wallof a blood vessel where it releases pharmaceutical agents to prevent arterial thromboses, plateletaggregation and/or excessive endothelial cell proliferation at the placement site. The stent may also beplaced in a blood vessel, bile duct, ureter, or fallopian tube or other duct or vessel, so that it deliversdrugs to specific body sites or organs.

q Detailed Description of The Invention

The mechanical support or stent of this invention may be formed from any of the materialsemployed in the prior art that are non-toxic to the blood and body tissue and otherwise biocompatable.The stent may be in the form of any structure that successfully preserves the luminal diameter of avessel or duct, and may operate by any mechanism known in the art.

The pharmaceutical agents suitable to be employed in this invention are too numerous to list. Theagents may be anticoagulants, antiplatelet substances, antispasmodics or drugs that inhibit excessiveendothelial cell growth, or they may be antimicrobial agents, hormones or anticancer drugs, or anycombination of these agents, or any others to accomplish any other localized purpose. The precisecoating or impregnating of the stent with the pharmaceutical agent will vary depending on the form andmaterial of the stent, and upon the pharmaceutical agent employed.

p q

a d

k

b p q

k

a d k i

p q

c

c

"CAM"

angiogenesis

angiogenesis

angiogenesis

CAM

d

i The tetracyclines can be

administered alone or in combination with, either before, simultaneously, or subsequentlyto treatment using conventional chemotherapeutic or radiation therapy.

Other chemotherapeutics include carmustine BCNU , 5-fluorouracil, - cyclodextrin,

vinca allcaloids such as vincristin, taxol and vinblastin, immunotoxins.

BCNU

k l

1 1

k l

1 2

k

q

1 2

American Heart Journal

Walter R. M. Hermans Prevention of restenosis after percutaneous

transluminal coronary angioplasty: The search for a "magic bullet"

Drugs Jean-Paul R. Herrman

Pharmacological Approaches to the Prevention of Restenosis Following

Angioplasty The Search for the Holy Grail? Part 1

Currier

Prevention of restenosis after percutaneous

transluminal coronary angioplasty: The search for a "magic bullet"

Barath

i j

j

1 2

1 2

k

l

HeLa

1 2

p q

MDAY-D2

BIOTECHNOLOGY Marsha

A. Moses INHIBITORS OF ANGIOGENESIS

Angiogenesis

TABLE 1

J.

Stenesh angiogenesis

angiogenesis

THE ANGIOGENIC PROCESS AND IN VIVO

ASSAYS FOR ANGIOGENESIS INHIBITORS

The two most commonly used in vivo assays are the rabbit corneal pocket

model and the CAM assay.

in vivo

"CAM"

d

SMC

J Am Coll Cardiol

Austin GE Intimal Proliferation of smooth muscle cells as an explanation

for recurrent coronary artery stenosis after percutaneous transluminal coronary

angioplasty.

JACC Peter Barath

LOW DOSE OF ANTITUMOR AGENTS PREVENTS SMOOTH MUSCLE

CELL PROLIFERATION AFTER ENDOTHELIAL INJURY

0.075mg/kg D 0.015mg/kg

Supplement Circulation Jesse V. Currier

Colchicine Inhibits Restenosis After Iliac Angioplasty in the Atherosclerotic

Rabbit

American Heart Journal Walter R. M.

Hermans Prevention of restenosis after percutaneous transluminal coronary

angioplasty: The search for a "magic bullet"

Table

Barath

0.075mg/kg D 0.015mg/kg

Drugs Jean-Paul R. Herrman Pharmacological

Approaches to the Prevention of Restenosis Following Angioplasty The Search for the

Holy Grail? Part 1

Colchicum autumnale

d

CANCER

RESEARCH Peter H. Wiernik Phase I Clinical and

Pharmacokinetic Study of Taxol

Annals of Internal

Medicine William P. McGuire Taxol: A Unique

Antineoplastic Agent with Signficant Activity in Advanced Ovarian Epithelial NeoplasmsJournal of Clinical

Oncology Raymond B. Weiss Hypersensitivity Reactions

from Taxol

HSR

HSR

Journal of the National

Cancer Institute Eric k. Rowinsky Taxol: A Novel

Investigational Antimicrotubule Agent

Journal of Clinical

Oncology Eric k. Rowinsky Cardiac Disturbances

During the Administration of Taxol

Seminars in Oncollogy

Eric k. Rowinsky Taxol: The First of the Taxanes, an

Important New Class of Antitumor Agents

H1- H2-

II 29

AV

Cremophor EL

Taxotere RP 56976

Clinical Pharmacy

R. Elizabeth Gregory Paclitaxel: A New Antineoplastic Agent for

Refractory Ovarian Cancer Paclitaxel

Journal of Clinical

Oncology Victoria Seewaldt Bowel Complications with

Taxol Therapy

e

出典:裁判所ウェブサイト「裁判例検索」(https://www.courts.go.jp/hanrei/35418/detail7/index.html)。本文は同サイト掲載の判決書PDFからTaiLexi AIがテキスト化・整形したもの(正確な文言は原本PDFを参照)。判示事項・裁判要旨・参照法条は裁判所の公表どおり。