TaiLexi AI日本の判例・法令
← ホーム
地裁

東京地判 平成23年7月5日

平成19年(行ウ)第391号等 原爆症認定申請却下処分取消等請求事件

判示事項

原子爆弾被爆者に対する援護に関する法律11条1項に基づく原爆症認定の各申請に対し,厚生労働大臣が,各申請者の疾病等には原爆放射線起因性がないとしてした,前記各申請を却下する旨の各処分の各取消請求が,一部認容された事例

続きを見る ↓

この判例について AI に質問

裁判所
東京地方裁判所
裁判年月日
平成23年7月5日 (2011-07-05)
事件番号
平成19年(行ウ)第391号等
事件名
原爆症認定申請却下処分取消等請求事件
裁判の種類・結果
判例集等
—
分野
行政

判示事項

原子爆弾被爆者に対する援護に関する法律11条1項に基づく原爆症認定の各申請に対し,厚生労働大臣が,各申請者の疾病等には原爆放射線起因性がないとしてした,前記各申請を却下する旨の各処分の各取消請求が,一部認容された事例

裁判要旨

原子爆弾被爆者に対する援護に関する法律11条1項に基づく原爆症認定の各申請に対し,厚生労働大臣が,各申請者の疾病等には原爆放射線起因性がないとしてした,前記各申請を却下する旨の各処分の各取消請求につき,訴訟における原爆放射線起因性の証明の有無の判断に当たっては,同法の目的及び趣旨を損なうことのないように,経験則に照らして全証拠を十分慎重に総合検討することが必要であるから,原爆放射線の影響が及んでいると疑われ,それに沿う相応の研究の成果が存在している疾病については,他の証拠との関係を十分慎重に総合検討すべきであり,また,平成20年3月17日に定められた,原爆症認定の運用に関する「新しい審査の方針」は,訴訟における原爆放射線起因性の証明の有無につき判断するに当たっても,関係する経験則の内容等に関する重要な目安となるとした上で,前記各申請者の各申請に係る疾病のうち,肺がん,狭心症,陳旧性心筋梗塞,脳梗塞,胸部大動脈瘤,甲状腺機能亢進症及び慢性肝炎について,原爆放射線起因性及び要医療性が認められるとして,前記各請求を一部認容した事例

(目次)

主文 ________________________________ - 13 -事実及び理由 _____________________________ - 14 -第1章請求の趣旨等 _____________________________ - 14 -

第1 請求の趣旨 ______________________________________________________- 14 -

第2 被告の本案前の答弁 ______________________________________________- 14 -第2章事案の概要 __________________________ - 14 -

第1 事案の概要等 ____________________________________________________- 14 -

1 事案の概要····································································································· - 14 -

2 当事者の略記について·················································································· - 15 -

第2 法令の定め ______________________________________________________- 15 -

1 被爆者援護法の制定趣旨等·········································································· - 15 -

2 被爆者等········································································································· - 16 -

(1) 被爆者········································································································· - 16 -

(2) 被爆者健康手帳·························································································· - 17 -

3 被爆者援護法上の被爆者に対する援護······················································· - 17 -

(1) 健康管理····································································································· - 17 -

(2) 医療············································································································· - 18 -

ア 医療の給付······························································································ - 18 -

イ 原爆症認定······························································································ - 19 -

ウ 医療の給付に代わる医療費の支給······················································· - 20 -

エ 一般疾病医療費の支給·········································································· - 21 -

(3) 手当等の支給······························································································ - 22 -

ア 医療特別手当の支給·············································································· - 22 -

イ 特別手当の支給······················································································ - 23 -

ウ 健康管理手当の支給·············································································· - 23 -

エ 保健手当の支給······················································································ - 25 -

オ 手当額の自動改定·················································································· - 26 -

第3 前提事実 ________________________________________________________- 26 -

1 原子爆弾の投下······························································································ - 26 -

2 被爆原告らの原爆症認定申請及び本件訴訟の提起等································ - 27 -

3 原爆症認定に関する審査の方針の策定及び改定等···································· - 27 -

4 新審査の方針による被爆原告らの一部の原爆症認定································ - 31 -

5 訴訟承継········································································································· - 31 -

第4 基礎的な概念等の認定 ____________________________________________- 32 -

第5 争点 ____________________________________________________________- 32 -

1 本案前の争点(争点1)·············································································· - 32 -

2 本案の争点····································································································· - 32 -

第6 争点に関する当事者の主張________________________________________- 33 -

1 争点1(認定済み原告らの訴えの利益)について···································· - 33 -

2 本案の争点について······················································································ - 33 -第3章当裁判所の判断 ____________________________________________- 33 -

第1 本案前の判断(争点1(認定済み原告らの訴えの利益)について) ___- 33 -

第2 認定事実 ________________________________________________________- 35 -

1 原子爆弾の爆発······························································································ - 35 -

(1) 広島の原子爆弾·························································································· - 35 -

(2) 長崎の原子爆弾·························································································· - 36 -

2 原爆被害に関する一般的知見······································································· - 37 -

(1) 原爆の物理的影響······················································································ - 37 -

ア 衝撃波及び爆風······················································································ - 37 -

イ 熱線········································································································· - 38 -

ウ 放射線····································································································· - 38 -(ア) 初期放射線·························································································· - 38 -(イ) 残留放射線·························································································· - 39 -

(2) 原爆による被害·························································································· - 39 -

ア 死亡········································································································· - 39 -

イ 爆風,衝撃波及び熱線による被害······················································· - 40 -

(長文のため、ここでは本文の冒頭のみを掲載しています。全文はこのページの表示後に読み込まれます。原本は原本PDFをご覧ください。)

出典:裁判所ウェブサイト「裁判例検索」(https://www.courts.go.jp/hanrei/82125/detail5/index.html)。本文は同サイト掲載の判決書PDFからTaiLexi AIがテキスト化・整形したもの(正確な文言は原本PDFを参照)。判示事項・裁判要旨・参照法条は裁判所の公表どおり。