審判番号 不服2021-650056
請求人 SMA Solar Technology AG(代理人 弁理士1名)
国際登録第1493388号に係る国際商標登録出願の拒絶査定に対する審判事件について、次のとおり審決する。
結論
原査定を取り消す。
本願商標は、登録すべきものとする。
理由
1 本願商標及び手続の経緯
本願商標は、「SMA」の文字を横書きしてなり、第9類、第16類、第35類、第37類から第42類に属する日本国を指定する国際登録において指定された商品及び役務を指定商品及び指定役務として、2019年(平成31年)1月25日にドイツ国においてした商標登録出願に基づいてパリ条約第4条による優先権を主張し、2019年(令和元年)7月18日に国際商標登録出願されたものである。
原審では、2020年(令和2年)11月4日付けで拒絶理由の通知、令和3年2月18日付けで意見書及び手続補正書の提出、2021年(令和3年)8月19日付けで拒絶査定されたもので、令和3年11月30日付けで本件拒絶査定不服審判が請求され、2021年(令和3年)10月28日付け、2022年(令和4年)6月22日付け及び同年7月25日付けで国際登録簿に記録された限定の通報があった。
本願の指定商品及び指定役務は、原審及び当審における上記の手続補正書及び限定により、第9類、第35類、第37類から第40類及び第42類に属する、別掲のとおりの商品及び役務に補正された。
2 原査定の拒絶の理由(要旨)
原査定は、「本願商標は、登録第5342554号商標、登録第5352491号商標及び登録第6277399号商標(以下、これらをまとめて「引用商標」という。)と同一又は類似の商標であって、同一又は類似の商品及び役務について使用をするものだから、商標法第4条第1項第11号に該当する。」旨認定、判断し、本願を拒絶したものである。
3 当審の判断
本願の指定商品及び指定役務は、上記1のとおり補正(限定)された結果、引用商標の指定商品及び指定役務と同一又は類似の商品及び役務は全て削除されたと認められるものである。
その結果、本願の指定商品及び指定役務は、引用商標の指定商品及び指定役務と類似しない商品及び役務になったと認められるものである。
したがって、本願商標が商標法第4条第1項第11号に該当するとして本願を拒絶した原査定の拒絶の理由は解消した。
その他、本願について拒絶の理由を発見しない。
よって、結論のとおり審決する。
令和4年12月26日
審判長 特許庁審判官 矢澤 一幸
特許庁審判官 杉本 克治
特許庁審判官 阿曾 裕樹
別掲(本願の指定商品及び指定役務)
第9類「Apparatus and instruments for conducting, switching, transforming, storing, regulating and controlling electricity; apparatus and instruments for measuring and analyzing electricity; software in the energy sector; mobile applications in the energy sector; electric display apparatus for use in the energy sector; data processing apparatus for use in the energy sector; inverters.」
第35類「Providing of an on-line market place for products and services relating to the energy sector; arranging commercial transactions, for others, via online shops in the energy sector; mediation and conclusion of commercial transactions in the energy sector; collection of commercial information for the energy sector; arranging of contractual services with third parties in the energy sector; advisory services relating to the conclusion of contractual services in the energy sector; mediation of contracts for the purchase and sale of products and services in the energy sector; advisory services relating to commercial transactions in the energy sector; provision of on-line business and commercial information in the energy sector; compilation and provision of trade and business price information in the energy sector; e-commerce services, namely consumer advice by means of telecommunication networks for advertising and sale purposes in the energy sector; provision of an online marketplace for buyers and sellers of goods and services in the energy sector; import-export agencies in the field of energy; energy price comparison services; assistance and consultancy services in the field of business management of companies in the energy sector; tracking and monitoring energy consumption for others by reading the meter for billing purposes; organizational and business consultancy relating to the design and provision of solution packages in the field of energy management.」
第37類「Installation services relating to devices for the energy sector; maintenance of energy generating installations; repair services of energy generating installations; assembly in the field of energy generating installations; energy generating installations cleaning services; laying of cable; assembly and repair of fences; installation, maintenance and repair of energy saving apparatus; installation, maintenance and repair of energy generating installations.」
第38類「Providing of access to online computer databases in the field of energy; providing of access to information on the Internet in the field of energy; telecommunication by means of platforms and portals on the Internet in the field of energy; providing of access to platforms and portals on the Internet in the field of energy; transfer of information and data via online services and via the Internet in the field of energy; providing of access to an electronic network for online research in the field of energy; telecommunication services in the field of energy; providing of telecommunication connection to a worldwide computer network in the field of energy; providing of telecommunication installations for the exchange of electronic data in the field of energy; online transfer of information in the field of energy; telecommunication services in the field of energy provided via platforms and portals on the Internet and other media; providing online forums in the field of energy; providing of access to information via data networks in the field of energy; electronic data exchange services in the field of energy; data transfer in the field of energy; communication services for the transmission of information in the field of energy; communication services by means of computer terminals, via digital transmission or via satellite in the field of energy; transmission of data, messages and information in the field of energy; provision of access to trade and business price and statistical information in the energy sector.」
第39類「Distribution of energy; storage of energy; information and advisory services relating to energy distribution; information and advisory services in the field of energy distribution and energy storage.」
第40類「Generation of power; energy production; leasing of energy generating equipment.」
第42類「Design, development and programming of software and apps for controlling energy systems; design, development and programming of energy management software and apps; design, development and programming of energy management systems and apps; design, development and programming of software and apps in the field of energy; rental of software and apps in the field of energy; installation and maintenance of software and apps in the field of energy; custom design of software packages and computer applications in the field of energy; monitoring of energy systems by remote access; recording data relating to energy consumption in buildings; measurement services in the field of energy; providing technical analysis relating to energy supply, energy generation and energy consumption by others; providing technical consultancy in the field of energy generation and energy consumption; technological consultancy in the fields of energy supply; technological advisory services in the field of energy; consultancy in the field of energy-saving, use of energy and energy efficiency; technical examination of the efficiency of energy consumption; energy auditing; certification services for the energy efficiency of buildings; providing technical advice relating to computers for energy systems; providing technical advice in the field of energy; technological analysis services in the field of energy; consultancy in the field of computer systems analysis in the field of energy; planning, design, development and maintenance of online websites for other in the field of energy; maintenance of websites and hosting on-line web facilities for others in the field of energy; software as a service (SaaS) in the field of energy; programming, maintenance and provision of non-downloadable software online via a worldwide computer network in the field of energy; programming, maintenance and provision of non- downloadable software and apps for e-commerce platforms in the field of energy; consultancy services relating to software and apps used in the field of e-commerce in the field of energy; providing temporary use of non-downloadable computer software for tracking packages over computer networks, intranets and the Internet in the field of energy; hosting platforms and portals in the field of energy; hosting platforms on the Internet in the field of energy; hosting of computerized data, files, applications and information in the field of energy; encryption, decryption and authentication of information, messages and data in the field of energy; cross-platform conversion of digital content into other forms of digital content; computer programming services for data warehousing in the field of energy; data conversion of electronic information in the field of energy; maintenance of software for data bases in the field of energy; engineering services relating to energy supply systems; engineering services in the field of energy technology; research in the field of energy; consultancy in the field of energy-saving; conversion of computer programs and data in the energy sector, excluding physical conversion; rental and maintenance of memory space for use as websites for third parties (hosting) in the field of energy; providing or rental of memory space (web space) on the Internet in the field of energy; provision of non-downloadable evaluation software online and provision of measuring apparatus for tracking energy consumption.」
出典:特許庁「審決公報」(令和5年9月29日発行・号数2023-009、公報発行サイト https://www.gazette.jpo.go.jp/scciidl010 )を加工して作成(加工:TaiLexi AI)
本文は公表資料(PDF 等)から機械的に抽出・整形したもので、改行や記号に誤りを含むことがあります。正確な文言は原本でご確認ください。