審判番号 不服2023-650022
請求人 BIOPOLIS S.L.(代理人 弁理士7名)
国際登録第1606707号に係る国際商標登録出願の拒絶査定に対する審判事件について、次のとおり審決する。
結 論
原査定を取り消す。
本願商標は、登録すべきものとする。
理 由
1 手続の経緯
本願は、2021年(令和3年)4月28日に国際商標登録出願されたものであって、その手続の経緯は以下のとおりである。
2022年(令和4年)5月11日付け:暫定拒絶通報
2022年(令和4年)8月25日 :意見書、手続補正書の提出
2022年(令和4年)9月5日 :上申書の提出
2022年(令和4年)11月30日 :上申書の提出
2022年(令和4年)12月7日付け:拒絶査定
2022年(令和4年)12月22日 :上申書の提出
2023年(令和5年)3月17日 :審判請求書、手続補正書の提出
2 本願商標
本願商標は、別掲1のとおりの構成よりなり、日本国を指定する国際登録において指定された第1類、第5類、第29類、第30類、第31類及び第32類に属する商品を指定商品として、2020年11月12日にEuropean Unionにおいてした商標登録出願に基づいてパリ条約第4条による優先権を主張し、国際商標登録出願されたものである。
その後、本願の指定商品については、原審及び当審における上記1の手続補正書により、最終的に別掲2のとおりに補正されたものである。
3 原査定の拒絶の理由(要旨)
原査定は、「本願商標は、登録第4667282号商標(以下「引用商標1」という。)及び登録第6363314号商標(以下「引用商標2」という。)と同一又は類似の商標であって同一又は類似の商品について使用をするものであるから、商標法第4条第1項第11号に該当する。」旨認定、判断し、本願を拒絶したものである。
4 当審の判断
本願の指定商品は、別掲2のとおり補正された結果、引用商標1及び引用商標2の指定商品と同一又は類似の商品は全て削除されたものと認められる。
その結果、本願の指定商品は、引用商標1及び引用商標2の指定商品と類似しないものになった。
したがって、本願商標が商標法第4条第1項第11号に該当するとして本願を拒絶した原査定の拒絶の理由は、解消した。
その他、本願について拒絶の理由を発見しない。
よって、結論のとおり審決する。
令和5年10月25日
審判長 特許庁審判官 豊瀬 京太郎
特許庁審判官 板谷 玲子
特許庁審判官 田中 瑠美
別掲1 本願商標(色彩は原本を参照。)
〔図省略〕
別掲2 補正後の本願の指定商品
第1類:Organic micro-organisms for use in the manufacture of food, beverages, pharmaceuticals and nutritional supplements, the aforementioned goods intended for humans or animals; probiotic bacterial cultures for the food and beverage industry as well as for use in pharmaceuticals, nutraceuticals and nutritional supplements; microorganisms for increasing the nutritional value of animal fodder (other than for veterinary use); all the aforesaid goods only for use in the human and animal food and pharmaceutical industries, and non-chemical.
第5類:Dietary supplements consisting mainly of probiotics; prebiotic supplements; probiotic preparations for medical use to help maintain a natural balance of flora in the digestive system; dietary and nutritional supplements; health food supplements for persons with special dietary requirements; powdered nutritional supplement drink mix; dietary supplement drinks mixes for use as meal replacements for medical use; nutritional supplements in the shape of bars for boosting energy as meal replacement; nutritional supplement energy bars; dietary supplements for humans with essential vitamins and microelements; dietetic food adapted for veterinary use; dietary supplements for animals; nutritional supplements for animals; infant formula; food and beverages for babies and infants; powdered milk for babies and infants; powdered milk foods for infants; dietary supplements for infants; dental care preparations for humans and animals containing probiotic supplements; medicated animal feed; food additives (medicated -) for animals; dietetic foods adapted for medical purposes; dietetic beverages adapted for medical purposes; nutritionally fortified food and beverages for medical purposes; dietetic foods and beverages for clinical nutrition; medicinal tea; medicated sweets; candy, medicated; intravenous fluids used for nutrition; oral care preparations [medicated]; medicated anti-cavity mouthwashes; nutritional additives for medical purposes.
第29類:Frozen vegetables; preserved vegetables; vegetables, dried; vegetables, cooked; fruit, preserved; dried fruit; frozen fruits; cooked fruits; jellies; jams; compotes; eggs; milk; cheese; milk products; oils and fats for food; milk-based beverages; almond milk; soya milk; rice milk; peanut milk; coconut milk; dairy products and dairy substitutes; chia milk; sesame milk; cream; sour cream; nut-based snack foods; fruit-based snack foods; milk products as snacks; seed-based snack foods; soy based snack foods; dairy products as snacks; yoghurts as snacks; dried fruit-based snacks; processed meat products as nutritionally fortified snack food; nutritionally fortified processed fruit and vegetables as snack food; seed-based snack food enriched with probiotics, prebiotics or postbiotics; nut-based snack food enriched with probiotics, prebiotics or postbiotics; almond-based snack food enriched with probiotics, prebiotics or postbiotics; soy-based snack food enriched with probiotics, prebiotics or postbiotics; dried fruit-based snack food enriched with probiotics, prebiotics or postbiotics; dairy products enriched with probiotics, prebiotics or postbiotics; fish based products enriched with probiotics, prebiotics or postbiotics; coffee creamer; cocoa butter for food; yoghurt; all the afore-mentioned goods with or without nutritional fortification; prepared meals consisting primarily of meat, fish or vegetables which contain nutrition products and/or nutraceuticals (for non-medical purposes); milk products which contain nutrition products and/or nutraceuticals (for non-medical purposes).
第30類:Artificial coffee; cocoa; coffee; rice; pasta; noodles; tapioca; sago; flour; preparations made from cereals; bread; pastries; confectionery; chocolate; ice-cream; sorbets; edible ices; sugar, honey, treacle; yeast; baking powder; salt; seasonings; spices; preserved herbs; vinegar; sauces; condiments; ice [frozen water]; coffee; coffee concentrates; coffee blends; coffee flavourings; coffee essences; malt coffee; coffee beverages with chocolate; coffee substitutes; iced coffee; coffee-based beverages; coffee-flavoured and/or coffee-bean-based snack bars consisting principally of coffee and also containing probiotics; cocoa-based beverages; cocoa mixes; candy with cocoa; cocoa-flavoured snack bars consisting principally of cocoa and also containing probiotics; sweets (candy); chewing gum; pastries, cakes, tarts and biscuits (cookies); cereal snacks; grain-based snack foods; cereal based snacks; wheat-based snack foods; corn-based savoury snacks; corn-based snack foods; rice-based snack foods; probiotic grainbased snack bars; probiotic cereal based snack bars; cereals; high-protein cereal bars; breakfast cereals containing fruit, fibre or honey; processed cereal products in the form of liquid being liquid meal replacement; cereal preparation; all the afore-mentioned goods with or without nutritional fortification; cereal bars which contain nutrition products and/or nutraceuticals (for non-medical purposes); processed grains which contain nutrition products and/or nutraceuticals (for non-medical purposes); pastries which contain nutrition products and/or nutraceuticals (for non-medical purposes); breakfast cereals containing seeds, fibre or honey which contain nutrition products and/or nutraceuticals (for non-medical purposes).
第31類:Animal food; animal beverages; cereals preparations being food for animals; animal feed preparations; powdered milk for animals; milk substitutes for use as foodstuffs for animals; all the afore-mentioned products with or without nutritional fortification.
第32類:Non-alcoholic beverages; mineral and aerated waters; fruit beverages and fruit juices; syrups and other non-alcoholic preparations for making beverages; beer; non-alcoholic beverages enriched with probiotics, prebiotics or postbiotics; energy drinks; sports drinks; powders, concentrates, extracts and essences used in the preparation of sports drinks; smoothies; fruit smoothies; vegetable smoothies; smoothies containing grains and oats; nonalcoholic beverages flavoured with coffee; non-alcoholic beverages flavoured with tea; non-alcoholic beverages enriched with vitamins, microelements, probiotics, prebiotics or postbiotics.
出典:特許庁「審決公報」(令和5年12月28日発行・号数2023-012、公報発行サイト https://www.gazette.jpo.go.jp/scciidl010 )を加工して作成(加工:TaiLexi AI)
本文は公表資料(PDF 等)から機械的に抽出・整形したもので、改行や記号に誤りを含むことがあります。正確な文言は原本でご確認ください。