審判番号 不服2024-650027
請求人 Forsta AS(代理人 弁護士1名、弁理士1名)
国際登録第1660820号に係る国際商標登録出願の拒絶査定に対する審判事件について、次のとおり審決する。
結論
原査定を取り消す。
本願商標は、登録すべきものとする。
理由
1 本願商標及び手続の経緯
本願商標は、別掲1のとおりの構成からなり、第9類、第35類、第38類、第41類及び第42類に属する日本国を指定する国際登録において指定された商品及び役務を指定商品及び指定役務として、2021年4月22日に英国においてした商標登録出願に基づいてパリ条約第4条(商標法第9条の2)による優先権を主張し、同年9月17日に、国際商標登録出願されたものである。
本願は、2023年2月15日付けで暫定的拒絶通報が通知され、同年11月9日付けで拒絶査定がされたもので、これに対して、令和6年4月15日に拒絶査定不服審判の請求がなされ、同日に手続補正書が提出されたものである。
そして、本願の指定商品及び指定役務は、上記手続補正書により、別掲2のとおり補正されたものである。
2 原査定の拒絶の理由の要点
原査定は、以下のとおり認定、判断し、本願を拒絶したものである。
(1)商標法第3条第1項柱書について
商標登録を受けることができる商標は、現在使用をしているもの又は近い将来使用をするものと解されるところ、本願の指定商品及び指定役務中、第41類の役務について、本願商標を使用しているか又は近い将来使用をすることについて疑義があるものである。したがって、本願商標は、商標法第3条第1項柱書の要件を具備していない。
(2)商標法第6条第1項について
本願の指定商品及び指定役務中に、その内容及び範囲を明確に指定したものとは認められない商品及び役務が含まれるから、本願は、商標法第6条第1項の要件を具備しない。
3 当審の判断
(1)商標法第3条第1項柱書について
本願の指定商品及び指定役務は、別掲2のとおり補正された結果、商標の使用又は使用の意思があることについての疑義がなくなったものと認められる。
したがって、本願商標が商標法第3条第1項柱書の要件を具備しないとして本願を拒絶した原査定の拒絶の理由は、解消した。
(2)商標法第6条第1項について
本願は、その指定商品及び指定役務について、別掲2のとおり補正された結果、その内容及び範囲が明確なものになったと認められる。
したがって、本願が商標法第6条第1項の要件を具備しないとして本願を拒絶した原査定の拒絶の理由は、解消した。
(3)まとめ
以上のとおり、本願を拒絶した原査定の拒絶の理由は、いずれも解消した。
その他、本願について拒絶の理由を発見しない。
よって、結論のとおり審決する。
令和7年1月22日
審判長 特許庁審判官 山田 啓之
特許庁審判官 石塚 文子
特許庁審判官 杉本 克治
別掲1 本願商標(色彩は原本を参照)
〔図省略〕
別掲2(本願の補正後の指定商品及び指定役務)
第9類「Downloadable video files of webinars, audio files of podcasts and downloadable video recordings; downloadable electronic publications; downloadable video files of webinars in the field of business, academic, market research, analysis, surveys, customer research, demographics, product and brand development, employee engagement, employee management, employee development and employer-employee relationships; video recordings featuring business, academic, market research, analysis, surveys, customer research, demographics, product and brand development, employee engagement, employee management, employee development and employer-employee relationships; downloadable electronic publications and video recordings in the nature of downloadable written articles about business, academic, market research, analysis, surveys, customer research, demographics, employee engagement, employee management, employee development and employer-employee relationships; downloadable video files of webinars and video recordings in the field of business, academic, market research, analysis, surveys, customer research, demographics, product and brand development, employee engagement, employee management, employee development and employer-employee relationships; downloadable electronic publications and video recordings in the nature of written articles about business, academic, market research, analysis, surveys, customer research, demographics, employee engagement, employee management, employee development and employer-employee relationships; downloadable computer software applications; downloadable computer software for processing and analyzing financial and market data; downloadable computer software for market analysis, customer surveys and performance measurement of financial markets; computer software for electronic processing of data; software applications arranging for participants to take part in multimedia or text surveys without an internet connection; computer software and downloadable software for electronic data processing (EDP) in the field of market analysis and consumer and employee surveys; computer software and downloadable software for data acquisition and market analysis.」
第35類「Business analysis, research and information services; business advice and consultancy relating to the design, customization and analysis of business concept testing surveys, employee evaluations, business engagement and feedback surveys, market surveys, business research surveys, academic business research surveys and customer surveys; providing and creating business analytics to assist in the management, tracking and application of survey data; providing business information on-line in the fields of market research statistics, customer satisfaction, employee engagement, brand development, brand evaluation, statistics for business or commercial purposes, online data collection for business research and surveys, market research, business management, business data analysis, customer research, demographics, brand development, employee engagement, employee management, employee development, and employer-employee relationships; business advice and consultancy relating to the design, customization and analysis of product research and concept testing surveys, employee evaluations, engagement and feedback surveys, market surveys, business research surveys, academic research surveys and customer surveys; business analysis to assist in the management, tracking and application of survey data; providing business information on-line in the fields of market research statistics, academic research statistics, customer satisfaction, employee engagement and product and brand development and testing; market research; business marketing consulting services; market research services, namely, sampling of survey populations for market research, data processing, online reporting of customer survey results, and custom community development for use in market research; market research services, namely, development of online surveys; market research consultation; market research, namely, providing focus groups for market research that are accessible by remote audio and video access; data processing services, namely, electronic data processing services [office function]; analysing and compiling business data for measuring the performance of financial markets; market analysis services; analysing of unstructured data and social media, namely, business and marketing data analysis; compilation of data into computer databases; business modelling consulting services, namely, business consulting, management, planning and supervision; information and data compiling and analyzing relating to business management.」
第38類「Electronic transmission of data and images of market research interviews; streaming of audio, visual and audiovisual material via a global computer network in the field of market research; video transmission of market research interviews over the internet using webconferencing and video streaming technology; providing video content management services for focus group research, namely, video teleconferencing and video-streaming.」
第41類「Provision of online non-downloadable electronic publications; provision of online non-downloadable videos; provision of tutorials, workshops and seminars; provision of educational information; providing online non-downloadable electronic publications and educational webinars in the field of statistics, popular culture, current events, historic events, online data collection, business, academic, market research, analysis, surveys, customer research, demographics, product and brand development, employee engagement, employee management, employee development and employer-employee relationships; providing educational information online in the field of popular culture, current events, historic events, academic research study, academic research statistics; conducting seminars, educational events in the nature of workshops, and classes about business, academic, market research, analysis, surveys, customer research, demographics, product and brand development, employee engagement, employee management, employee development and employer-employee relationships; arranging and conducting awards ceremonies to promote excellence in the field of business, academic, market research, analysis, surveys, customer research, demographics, product and brand development, employee engagement, employee management, employee development and employer-employee relationships; education and entertainment services in the form of production of digital and motion picture films, radio and television programs and television shows; providing educational information online about research conducted by educational institutions; providing online non-downloadable electronic publications and educational webinars in the field of statistics, popular culture, current events, historic events, online data collection, business, academic, market research, analysis, surveys, customer research, demographics, product and brand development, employee engagement, employee management, employee development and employer-employee relationships; providing educational and entertainment information online in the field of statistics, popular culture, current events, historic events, online data collection, business, academic, market research, analysis, surveys, customer research, demographics, product and brand development, employee engagement, employee management, employee development and employer-employee relationships; education and entertainment services in the form of production of digital and motion picture films, radio and television programs and shows; providing video content management services for focus group research, namely, videotape production services.」
第42類「Providing software as a service (SAAS) to measure, prioritize, and optimize the customer, product, employee and brand responses, and to display relevant concurrences using statistically driven data sets; software as a service (SAAS) in the fields of business research, academic research, market research, market development and market growth, consumer research and customer satisfaction surveys, product research, brand research and concept testing surveys, employee evaluations and feedback surveys, all to measure, prioritize, and optimize the customer, product, employee and brand responses, and to display relevant concurrences using statistically driven data sets; software as a service (SAAS) for designing, conducting and analyzing surveys, survey data and consumer feedback; software as a service (SAAS) for providing and creating analytics to assist in the management, tracking and application of survey and contact data; providing temporary use of non-downloadable computer software accessed via the internet in the field of business, academic, market research, analysis, surveys, customer research, demographics, product and brand development, employee engagement, employee management, employee development, and employer employee relationships, all to measure, prioritize, and optimize the customer, product, employee and brand responses, and to display relevant concurrences using statistically driven data sets; providing software as a service (SAAS), accessed via the internet and offline featuring software for contact information, data feedback, data evaluation, and research surveys, data collection, data integration, data management, data analysis, follow-up to survey responses and generating reports for use in consulting with respect thereto; computer services, namely, hosting an on-line web site and web facilities for others for conducting consumer surveys, employee surveys and business research and analyzing resulting data; providing information online in the field of product development and product testing; computer website design, namely, design of education and entertainment blogs; advising and consulting in connection with the design, customization and analysis of product research; SAAS in the fields of business research, academic research, market research, market development and market growth, consumer research and customer satisfaction surveys, product research, brand research and concept testing surveys, employee evaluations and feedback surveys; SAAS for designing, conducting and analyzing surveys, survey data and consumer feedback; SAAS for providing and creating analytics to assist in the management, tracking and application of survey and contact data; providing temporary use of non-downloadable computer software accessed via the internet in the field of business, academic, market research, analysis, surveys, customer research, demographics, product and brand development, employee engagement, employee management, employee development and employer-employee relationships; providing information online in the field of product development and testing; computer programming of software for purposes of electronic data processing; technological consultancy in the field of the design, selection, implementation and use of computer hardware and software for others; rental of computer software; computer programming for others; computer programming of computer software in the fields of electronic data processing, employment, employer and employee relations, customer feedback management, and market research; computer services, namely, computer programming for software platforms to enable registered users to receive feedback from employees; computer consulting services, namely, design and implementation of software platforms to enable registered users to receive feedback from employees; providing temporary use of on-line non-downloadable software for use in performing and compiling market research; providing temporary use of online non-downloadable software for the design and development of marketing campaigns, performing and compiling market research, organizing and analyzing market research data in the field of market research; software as a service (SaaS) services featuring software for the collection, storage, organization, management, searching, manipulation and analysis of data in the fields of marketing, marketing research, qualitative and quantitative research and focus groups; software as a service (SaaS) services featuring software for management of marketing and market research projects; providing temporary use of online, non-downloadable software for electronic transmission of data and images by video broadcasting of market research interviews; providing temporary use of online, non-downloadable software for streaming of audio, visual and audiovisual material via a global computer network and wireless broadcasting in the field of market research; platform as a service (PAAS) services featuring software for electronic transmission of data and images by video broadcasting of market research interviews; platform as a service (PAAS) services featuring software for streaming of audio, visual and audiovisual material via a global computer network and wireless broadcasting in the field of market research; providing termporary use of online non-downloadable software for use in designing surveys for market research use; software as a service (SaaS) services featuring software for management of marketing and market research projects, including creation and tracking of budgets for such projects and management of vendors; software as a service (SAAS) services featuring software for creating and deploying online dashboard reporting solutions for market research and customer experience management.」
出典:特許庁「審決公報」(令和7年4月25日発行・号数2025-004、公報発行サイト https://www.gazette.jpo.go.jp/scciidl010 )を加工して作成(加工:TaiLexi AI)
本文は公表資料(PDF 等)から機械的に抽出・整形したもので、改行や記号に誤りを含むことがあります。正確な文言は原本でご確認ください。