審判番号 不服2024-650074
請求人 YANDEX LLC(代理人 弁理士4名)
国際登録第1517103号に係る国際商標登録出願の拒絶査定に対する審判事件について、次のとおり審決する。
結論
原査定を取り消す。
本願商標は、登録すべきものとする。
理由
1 手続の経緯
本願は、2019年(令和元年)8月21日にRussian Federationにおいてした商標登録出願に基づいてパリ条約第4条による優先権を主張し、2020年(令和2年)1月23日に国際商標登録出願されたものであって、その手続の経緯は以下のとおりである。
2021年(令和3年)3月31日付け:暫定拒絶通報
2021年(令和3年)6月22日 :限定の通報
2023年(令和5年)7月24日付け:拒絶査定
2024年(令和6年)8月7日 :審判請求書の提出
2024年(令和6年)9月4日 :手続補正書の提出
2 本願商標
本願商標は、「CatBoost」の欧文字を横書きしてなり、日本国を指定する国際登録において指定された第9類に属する商品及び第35類、第38類、第39類、第41類及び第42類に属する役務を指定商品及び指定役務として、国際商標登録出願されたものである。
その後、本願の指定商品及び指定役務は、原審における限定の通報及び当審における上記1の手続補正書により、最終的に、別掲のとおりに補正されたものである。
3 原査定の拒絶の理由(要旨)
原査定は、以下の(1)及び(2)のとおり認定、判断し、本願を拒絶したものである。
(1)商標法第6条第1項について
本願の指定商品及び指定役務は、その内容及び範囲を明確に指定したものとは認められない商品及び役務を包含しているから、本願は、商標法第6条第1項の要件を具備しない。
(2)商標法第3条第1項柱書について
ア 本願は、第9類及び第35類において、広い範囲にわたる商品及び役務を指定しており、また、それらの指定商品及び指定役務は、全く業種が異なり、類似の関係にないものであるため、出願人(請求人)が、本願商標をこれらの指定商品及び指定役務の全てについて使用しているか、又は近い将来使用をすることについて疑義がある。
イ 本願において指定した小売等役務(商標法第2条第2項に規定する役務。以下同じ。)は、全く業種が異なり、類似の関係にもないものであるため、出願人(請求人)が本願商標をこれらの小売等役務のいずれにも使用しているか、又は近い将来使用をすることについて疑義がある。
ウ 上記ア及びイのとおり、本願商標は、商標法第3条第1項柱書の要件を具備しない。
4 当審の判断
(1)商標法第6条第1項について
本願の指定商品及び指定役務は、当審における上記1の手続補正書により、別掲のとおり補正された結果、その内容及び範囲が明確なものになったと認められる。
したがって、本願が商標法第6条第1項の要件を具備しないとして本願を拒絶した原査定の拒絶の理由は、解消した。
(2)商標法第3条第1項柱書について
本願の指定商品及び指定役務は、当審における上記1の手続補正書により、別掲のとおり補正された結果、商標の使用又は使用の意思があることについての疑義がなくなったものと認められる。
したがって、本願商標が商標法第3条第1項柱書の要件を具備しないとして本願を拒絶した原査定の拒絶の理由は、解消した。
(3)まとめ
以上のとおり、本願を拒絶した原査定の拒絶の理由は、いずれも解消した。
その他、本願についての拒絶の理由を発見しない。
よって、結論のとおり審決する。
令和6年12月18日
審判長 特許庁審判官 大森 友子
特許庁審判官 小俣 克巳
特許庁審判官 田中 瑠美
別掲 補正後の本願の指定商品及び指定役務
第9類 coin-operated musical automata [juke boxes]; monitoring apparatus, other than for medical purposes; sound recording apparatus; global positioning system [gps] apparatus; telephone apparatus; electronic tags for goods; mechanical signs; signs, luminous; loudspeakers; dictating machines; electronic numeric displays; electronic interactive whiteboards; electronic notice boards; electronic book readers; audio interfaces; simulators for the steering and control of vehicles; measuring instruments; interfaces for computers; identity cards, magnetic; encoded magnetic cards; encoded key cards; electronic agendas; computers; laptop computers; tablet computers; notebook computers; wearable computers; microtomes; modems; monitors [computer hardware]; monitors [computer programs]; headphones; sound recording carriers; magnetic data media; optical data media; electronic sheet music, downloadable; computer software, recorded; computer hardware; selfie lenses; signalling panels, luminous or mechanical; electronic pocket translators; transmitters [telecommunication]; telephone transmitters; transmitters of electronic signals; computer software platforms, recorded or downloadable; wafers for integrated circuits; digital signs; personal digital assistants; distance measuring apparatus; speed checking apparatus for vehicles; teaching apparatus; weighing apparatus and instruments; navigational instruments; measuring apparatus; measuring devices, electric; observation instruments; navigation apparatus for vehicles [on-board computers]; satellite navigational apparatus; regulating apparatus, electric; telecommunication apparatus in the form of jewellery; audio- and video-receivers; computer software applications, downloadable; computer programs, recorded; computer game software; computer programs [downloadable software]; computer operating programs, recorded; computer screen saver software, recorded or downloadable; processors [central processing units]; electronic publications, downloadable; control panels [electricity]; radar apparatus; vehicle radios; walkie-talkies; voltage regulators for vehicles; security surveillance robots; laboratory robots; teaching robots; humanoid robots with artificial intelligence; optical fibers [light conducting filaments]; traffic-light apparatus [signalling devices]; signals, luminous or mechanical; electronic access control systems for interlocking doors; scanners [data processing equipment]; integrated circuit cards [smart cards]; smartglasses; smartphones; personal digital assistants in the shape of watches; speed indicators; audiovisual teaching apparatus; charging stations for electric vehicles; integrated circuits; kilometer recorders for vehicles; taximeters; cellular phones; mobile telephones; interactive touch screen terminals; thermostats for vehicles; vehicle breakdown warning triangles; gauges; computer software for automatic steering apparatus for vehicles; video recorders; sound reproduction apparatus; data processing apparatus; optical character readers; sound alarms; anti-theft warning apparatus; computer peripheral devices; acoustic couplers; whistle alarms; downloadable ring tones for mobile phones; downloadable image files; downloadable music files; animated cartoons; usb flash drives; cases for smartphones; covers for personal digital assistants; covers for tablet computers; covers for smartphones; virtual reality headsets; downloadable graphics for mobile phones; eyeglasses; sunglasses; security tokens [encryption devices]; wearable activity trackers; bar code readers.
第35類 Commercial information agencies; advertising agencies; rental of advertising space; employment agencies; computerized file management; accounting; invoicing; demonstration of goods; opinion polling; market studies; business information; commercial information and advice for consumers in the choice of products and services; business research; marketing research; personnel recruitment; business management and organization consultancy; business organization consultancy; business management consultancy; personnel management consultancy; professional business consultancy; consultancy regarding public relations communication strategies; consultancy regarding advertising communication strategies; layout services for advertising purposes; marketing; marketing in the framework of software publishing; targeted marketing; updating and maintenance of data in computer databases; organization of exhibitions for commercial or advertising purposes; payroll preparation; data search in computer files for others; sponsorship search; commercial intermediation services; providing business information via a web site; provision of commercial and business contact information; provision of an on-line marketplace for buyers and sellers of goods and services; web indexing for commercial or advertising purposes; presentation of goods on communication media, for retail purposes; economic forecasting; auctioneering; sales promotion for others; promotion of goods and services through sponsorship of sports events; production of advertising films; rental of advertising time on communication media; publicity material rental; rental of billboards [advertising boards]; rental of vending machines; rental of sales stands; publication of publicity texts; radio advertising; dissemination of advertising matter; direct mail advertising; registration of written communications and data; advertising; on-line advertising on a computer network; outdoor advertising; advertising by mail order; television advertising; compilation of statistics; compilation of information into computer databases; business inquiries; systemization of information into computer databases; advisory services for business management; compiling indexes of information for commercial or advertising purposes; tax preparation; drawing up of statements of accounts; telemarketing services; administration of consumer loyalty programs; administration of frequent flyer programs; administrative processing of purchase orders; public relations; market intelligence services; web site traffic optimisation; preparation of documents related to taxation; search engine optimisation for sales promotion; price comparison services; pay per click advertising; procurement services for others [purchasing goods and services for other businesses]; word processing; business assistance related to outsourcing.
第38類 Electronic bulletin board services; information about telecommunication; providing access to databases; providing internet chatrooms; video-on-demand transmission; transmission of greeting cards online; message sending; computer aided transmission of messages and images; transmission of telegrams; transmission of digital files; providing online forums; videoconferencing services; rental of message sending apparatus; rental of modems; rental of telecommunication equipment; rental of telephones; transmission of electronic mail; paging services [radio, telephone or other means of electronic communication]; voice mail services; telecommunications routing and junction services; streaming of data.
第39類 Motor coach rental; boat rental; garage rental; rental of vehicle roof racks; aircraft rental; parking place rental; rental of warehouses; booking of seats for travel; travel reservation; transport reservation; towing; vehicle breakdown towing services; delivery of newspapers; message delivery; parcel delivery; delivery of goods; delivery of goods by mail order; flower delivery; traffic information; transportation information; storage information; transportation logistics; arranging of cruises; arranging of transportation for travel tours; armored-car transport; hauling; carting; transporting furniture; removal services; transport of travellers; guarded transport of valuables; bus transport; car transport; boat transport; passenger transport; porterage; transport brokerage; freight brokerage; providing driving directions for travel purposes; car rental; rental of motor racing cars; vehicle rental; stevedoring; unloading cargo; packaging of goods; escorting of travellers; wrapping of goods; car parking; chauffeur services; pleasure boat transport; car sharing services; courier services [messages or merchandise]; taxi transport; transport; transport services for sightseeing tours; physical storage of electronically stored data or documents; storage of goods; warehousing; freight forwarding.
第41類 Academies [education]; publication of books; education information; recreation information; entertainment information; layout services, other than for advertising purposes; microfilming; videotape editing; production of radio and television programmes; providing online electronic publications, not downloadable; game services provided online from a computer network; correspondence courses; practical training [demonstration]; training services provided via simulators; providing recreation facilities; arranging and conducting of colloquiums; arranging and conducting of congresses; arranging and conducting of conferences; arranging and conducting of workshops [training]; arranging and conducting of in-person educational forums; arranging and conducting of seminars; organization of competitions [education or entertainment]; vocational guidance [education or training advice]; television entertainment; mobile library services; vocational retraining; providing online videos, not downloadable; providing online music, not downloadable; providing television programs, not downloadable, via video-on-demand services; providing films, not downloadable, via video-on-demand services; educational examination; educational examination for users to qualify to pilot drones; electronic desktop publishing; online publication of electronic books and journals; publication of texts, other than publicity texts; entertainment services; news reporters services; tutoring; teaching; educational services provided by schools; coaching [training]; nursery schools.
第42類 Computer systems analysis; recovery of computer data; computer virus protection services; installation of computer software; mechanical research; scientific research; technological research; web site design consultancy; computer security consultancy; information technology [IT] consultancy; consultancy in the design and development of computer hardware; internet security consultancy; computer software consultancy; data security consultancy; consultation of technological research; quality control; vehicle roadworthiness testing; updating of computer software; monitoring of computer systems to detect breakdowns; monitoring of computer systems for detecting unauthorized access or data breach; monitoring of computer systems by remote access; software as a service [SaaS]; maintenance of computer software; conversion of data or documents from physical to electronic media; providing information on computer technology and programming via a web site; providing search engines for the internet; conversion of computer programs and data, other than physical conversion; conducting technical project studies; computer system design; rental of web servers; computer rental; rental of computer software; hosting computer sites [web sites]; server hosting; computer software design; creating and designing website-based indexes of information for others [information technology services]; creating and maintaining web sites for others; computer programming; technical writing; copying of computer programs; cloud computing; implementation, rental, updating and maintenance of computer programs and software, for others, and consultancy services relating thereto; off-site data backup; computer technology consultancy; consultation of technological research relating to telecommunication apparatus; cartography services; data encryption services; electronic data storage; surveying; electronic monitoring of credit card activity to detect fraud via the internet; electronic monitoring of personally identifying information to detect identity theft via the internet.
出典:特許庁「審決公報」(令和7年5月30日発行・号数2025-005、公報発行サイト https://www.gazette.jpo.go.jp/scciidl010 )を加工して作成(加工:TaiLexi AI)
本文は公表資料(PDF 等)から機械的に抽出・整形したもので、改行や記号に誤りを含むことがあります。正確な文言は原本でご確認ください。