TaiLexi AI日本の判例・法令
← ホーム
審決特許庁成立

特許庁審決 令和8年3月19日

不服2023-650078 国際登録第1209295号に係る国際商標登録出願の拒絶査定に対する審判事件

AI 要約AI

国際商標登録出願につき、国際登録原簿に記録された商品等限定通報により指定商品及び指定役務が限定された結果、商標法第6条第1項の要件及び商標法第3条第1項柱書の要件をいずれも具備しないとした原査定の拒絶の理由が解消したとして、原査定を取り消し、本願商標を登録すべきものとした事例。

続きを見る ↓AI が判決本文から作成した要約です(誤りを含む可能性があります)。

この資料について AI に質問

機関
特許庁
年月日
令和8年3月19日 (2026-03-19)
事件番号
不服2023-650078
事件名
国際登録第1209295号に係る国際商標登録出願の拒絶査定に対する審判事件
種類・結果
審決 成立
掲載
—
争点・税目
拒絶査定不服審判 / 商標
分野
知的財産

結論

原査定を取り消す。

本願商標は、登録すべきものとする。

AI 要約AI

要旨

  • 国際商標登録出願につき、国際登録原簿に記録された商品等限定通報により指定商品及び指定役務が限定された結果、商標法第6条第1項の要件及び商標法第3条第1項柱書の要件をいずれも具備しないとした原査定の拒絶の理由が解消したとして、原査定を取り消し、本願商標を登録すべきものとした事例。
事案の概要・争点・判断などを表示

事案の概要

  • 本願商標は、別掲1のとおりの構成よりなり、第7類、第9類ないし第12類、第17類、第35類ないし第37類、第40類ないし第42類及び第44類に属する国際登録において指定された商品及び役務を指定商品及び指定役務として、2013年(平成25年)4月8日に国際商標登録出願されたものである。
  • 原査定は、本願の指定商品及び指定役務中にその内容及び範囲を明確に指定したものとは認められない商品及び役務が含まれるとして商標法第6条第1項の要件を具備せず、また、広範な範囲にわたる商品及び役務を指定しているため出願人が全てについて使用しているか又は近い将来使用をすることについて疑義があるとして商標法第3条第1項柱書の要件を具備しないと認定、判断して本願を拒絶した。
  • 2024年(令和6年)10月22日付けで国際登録簿に記録された限定の通報により、指定商品及び指定役務は別掲2に記載の商品及び役務に限定された。出願人は、拒絶査定不服審判を請求した。

争点

  • 本願の指定商品及び指定役務が商標法第6条第1項の要件を具備するか否か。
  • 本願商標が商標法第3条第1項柱書の要件を具備するか否か。

判断

  • 本願は、その指定商品及び指定役務について別掲2のとおり限定された結果、その内容及び範囲が明確なものとなったと認められるから、商標法第6条第1項の要件を具備しないとして本願を拒絶した原査定の拒絶の理由は解消した。
  • 本願は、その指定商品及び指定役務について別掲2のとおりに限定された結果、商標の使用又は使用の意思があることについては疑義がなくなったから、商標法第3条第1項柱書の要件を具備しないとして本願を拒絶した原査定の拒絶の理由は解消した。
  • 以上のとおり、本願を拒絶した原査定の拒絶の理由は、いずれも解消し、その他、本願について拒絶の理由を発見しない。

結論

  • 原査定を取り消す。
  • 本願商標は、登録すべきものとする。

AI が本文から作成した要約です。引用の際は本文をご確認ください。

当事者

請求人 General Electric Company(代理人 弁理士2名)

審判番号 不服2023-650078

請求人 General Electric Company(代理人 弁理士2名)

国際登録第1209295号に係る国際商標登録出願の拒絶査定に対する審判事件について、次のとおり審決する。

結論

原査定を取り消す。

本願商標は、登録すべきものとする。

理由

1 手続の経緯

本願商標は、2013年(平成25年)4月8日に国際商標登録出願されたものであって、その手続の経緯は以下のとおりである。

2014年(平成26年)12月25日付け:暫定拒絶通報

2023年(令和5年)5月24日付け:拒絶査定

2023年(令和5年)9月8日  :審判請求書の提出

2024年(令和6年)10月22日付け:国際登録原簿に記録された商品等限定通報

2 本願商標

本願商標は、別掲1のとおりの構成よりなり、第7類、第9類ないし第12類、第17類、第35類ないし第37類、第40類ないし第42類及び第44類に属する国際登録において指定された商品及び役務を指定商品及び指定役務として、2013(平成25年)年4月8日に国際商標登録出願されたものである。

その後、指定商品及び指定役務については、2024年(令和6年)10月22日付けで国際登録簿に記録された限定の通報により、別掲2に記載の商品及び役務に限定されたものである。

3 原査定の拒絶の理由の要点

原査定は、以下のとおり認定、判断し、本願を拒絶したものである。

(1)商標法第6条第1項

本願の指定商品及び指定役務中に、その内容及び範囲を明確に指定したものとは認められない商品及び役務が含まれるから、本願は、商標法第6条第1項の要件を具備しない。

(2)商標法第3条第1項柱書

商標法第3条第1項柱書により商標登録を受けることができる商標は、現在使用をしているもの又は近い将来使用をするものと解される。しかし、本願は、第7類、第9類、第11類、第37類において、広範な範囲にわたる商品及び役務を指定しているため、出願人が出願に係る商標をそれらの指定商品及び指定役務の全てについて使用しているか又は近い将来使用をすることについて疑義があるといわざるを得ない。

したがって、本願商標は、商標法第3条第1項柱書の要件を具備しない。

4 当審の判断

(1)商標法第6条第1項について

本願は、その指定商品及び指定役務について、別掲2のとおり限定された結果、その内容及び範囲が明確なものとなったと認められる。

したがって、本願は、商標法第6条第1項の要件を具備しないとして本願を拒絶した原査定の拒絶の理由は解消した。

(2)商標法第3条第1項柱書について

本願は、その指定商品及び指定役務について、別掲2のとおりに限定された結果、商標の使用又は使用の意思があることについては、疑義がなくなった。

したがって、本願は、商標法第3条第1項柱書の要件を具備しないとして本願を拒絶した原査定の拒絶の理由は解消した。

(3)まとめ

以上のとおり、本願を拒絶した原査定の拒絶の理由は、いずれも解消した。

その他、本願について拒絶の理由を発見しない。

よって、結論のとおり審決する。

令和8年3月19日

審判長 特許庁審判官 旦 克昌

特許庁審判官 小林 裕子

特許庁審判官 武谷 逸平

別掲1 本願商標

〔図省略〕

別掲2 本願指定商品及び指定役務

第7類「Machines for domestic and household use, namely, electronic power operated coffee grinders; mechanical mixing machines; electric food blenders for domestic use; electric juice extractors; electric food processors, and electric food preparation machines, vegetable grinders and slicers; electric motors other than for land vehicles, steam and gas turbines and parts thereof; electric generators and their parts; aircraft engines; gas compressors, air-conditioning compressors; washing machines; washing machines [laundry] with a drying function; dishwashers; garbage disposers and compactors; electric knives; electric can openers; axial and centrifugal compressors; reciprocating compressors; screw and vane compressors; rotary, vacuum, electric, submersible and centrifugal pumps; turbo expanders, namely, air and electric compressors; CNG fuel dispensing machines for land vehicles and for internal combustion engines and parts and fittings thereof; fuel pumps for land vehicle engines; fuel filters; steam condensers; pumps, namely, centrifugal pumps, diaphragm pumps, bellows pumps and process and transfer pumps for water and wastewater treatment systems; pressure regulators [parts of machines]; filter cartridges for various industrial machines for filtration applications, namely, for the filtration of beer in the brewing industry, and other specialty chemicals; machines for the feeding and application of chemicals for industrial uses; boat engines, turbochargers for engines, and fuel injectors; vehicle engine parts, namely, high frequency motor spindles with high frequency electric converters and power supply units, rocker arms, push rods, oil coolers, crankcase breathers, oil tanks, ignition parts for internal combustion engines, namely, points, radiators, water pumps, starter motors, pumps for cooling engines, engine bearings, engine camshafts, engine rods and engine mufflers; apparatus, equipment and instruments for the generation of power, namely, electric generators and wind powered electricity generators; turbines; turbines for power generation; wind turbines for power generation; engines for the generation of electricity, and parts and fittings for all the aforesaid; electrical power generation products.」

第9類「Navigation apparatus for vehicles in the nature of on-board computers; optical inspection apparatus for railway system use; railway signals, namely, crossing warning systems; high-frequency switching power supplies; electrical engine controllers; global positioning system (GPS) consisting of computers, computer software, transmitters, receivers, and network interface devices for the rail and transit industries; electrical devices and electrical power distribution products, namely, capacitors, circuit breakers, circuit breaker load centers, circuit closers, circuit interrupters, commutators, contactors, current rectifiers, current limiters, electric contacts, electric collectors, electric conductors, electric connectors, electric controllers, electric inductors, electric power supplies, electricity distribution boards and boxes, electricity distribution consoles, electricity switchboards, and switchboxes; computer software for persons who troubleshoot and maintain programmable controllers; computer software for analyzing blood vessels including cardiac vessels which also provides calculation functions with respect to blood vessels; computer software for use with medical patient monitoring equipment; computer software for receiving, processing, transmitting and displaying data, for use in developing personalized asset allocation programs; computer software for collecting data involving vital medical signs; computer software for use in electrical power systems analyses; computer software for regulating and managing vehicle fleet maintenance services; computer software for use by customers to obtain lease portfolio information; computer software for a radiology information system for use by radiologists and radiology departments in the database management of employee and patient information; computer software for graphical user interface; computer software for underground navigation, namely, for navigation of down-hole probe assembly for oil drilling and drilling assemblies for routing underground utilities; telephones; telephone answering machines; cordless telephones, cordless headset telephones; digital messaging systems; televisions; television remote controls; DVD players; DVD remote controls; batteries; electrical power distribution machines and electrical voltage and overvoltage surge protectors, namely, lightning arresters, contractors, power controllers, and input/output electrical power supplies; fuses; lighting controllers; switch boxes; LEDs, namely, light emitting diodes; voltage regulators for electric power; voltage surge protectors; voltage surge suppressors; voltmeters; electric relays; self-timers for cameras; limit switches; full-voltage power supply; low voltage power supply; electrical switches and disconnects; circuit boards; electrical terminal blocks; panels for circuit boards; transformers; electrical circuit boards; distribution boards [electricity]; electrical wires; cables and conductors; electrical wiring and fixtures; lightning arrestors; electricity meters; power meters; grounding resistors; humidity and temperature sensors; industrial calibration sensors; motor control centers; electric resistances; electrical controllers; apparatus for electrophoresis not for medical purposes; chromatography columns and pumps for laboratory use; apparatus for conformations systems, namely, computer hardware and software for processing biological information; scintillation counter to measure beta-emitting nuclides; imaging apparatus for radioactive and luminescent emissions, namely, CCD cameras and scanners; synthesis and purification integrated systems, namely, chromatography columns, cartridges, fraction collectors, laboratory mixers, monitors, laboratory pumps, recorders (measuring devices), and analysis software; laboratory apparatus and instruments for microarrays, namely, probes, slides, buffers, bacterial controls, racks, and trays; laboratory glassware; computer software for hospital operating room management; computer software for critical care information management; industrial process control software; computers and instructional manuals in electronic format sold as a unit for use in factory management; software for creating graphics displays and editing dynamic data interfaces for real time graphics applications for industrial and business applications; communications software for connecting computer network users; factory automation software for control, monitoring, simulation, communications, data logging and collection, and factory automation; software to integrate manufacturing machine operations, control processes, to provide data for visualization, to track problems and generate production reports; packaged software for use in the operation and programming of grinding machines in the manufacturing industry; industrial process control hardware, namely, computer monitors, laptop computers, LAN [local area network] cards and cables; computer networking hardware; memory cards; microchips; microprocessors; computer network hubs, switches and routers; computer displays and terminals; computer whiteboards; system boards and processors; industrial process control software; manufacturing execution systems and document management software; digital signal processing products and systems, namely, industrial automation controls and programmable logic controllers; electronic control systems for machines tools in the nature of an external controller to optimize machine tool cutting performance of rough and semi-rough cuts; power supplies and mounting hardware; intrusion and burglar alarm systems; security devices, namely, programming logic computers, control panels, electronic intrusion detectors, electronic glass-break sensors, electronic vibration sensors, magnetic contacts for use in security systems, electronic switch plates, electronic motion sensors for alarm systems, electronic motion sensitive switches, hardwire sirens, audio speakers, electronic speaker drivers, access control and alarm monitoring systems; fire, heat, and smoke detecting and alarm units; computer card operated access control systems; card readers, card encoders, and encoded cards for use with card operated access control systems; video cameras; biometric access control systems; biometric identification systems; apparatus for detecting the position, location and shape of objects; GPS tracking and location devices; automated license plate readers; video surveillance systems; video alarm management systems; biometric identification apparatus; apparatus for locating and positioning vehicles; traffic detectors; apparatus and installations for access control; intrusion detectors; anti-intrusion alarms; processing hardware and software that analyzes digital video images to automatically extract, record, and report intelligence; remote video monitoring systems for security and surveillance applications; central video monitors; cameras; short range wireless radio frequency transceivers; power line transceivers; communication control hardware, namely, keypad controllers, matrix switches, multiplexes, digital video recorders, integrated pan-tilt-zoom domes, remote video controllers, and electronic alarms; video transmission devices in the nature of video transmitters sold separately or as part of a system for operating closed circuit cameras; fiber-optic transmission systems, namely, fiber optic transmitters, receivers, and transceivers used in the transmission of video, audio, and data signals over optical fiber; electro-mechanical locks; magnetic locks; electric keys; handheld computers for receiving, controlling, storing, manipulating, displaying, transmitting data and for operating electronic locks; card readers; magnetic encoders; keypads for access control systems; radio frequency tracking tags; tracking systems comprising one or more radio frequency tags, transceivers, and sensors used to determine and monitor the location and movement of tangible assets, of inventory, and of individuals; infrared sensors; computer hardware and software for facilities management and controlling facility access systems and components therefor, namely, control panels, access card readers, and equipment and systems for video imaging, video monitoring, digital hard drive recording, network transmission and remote access; computer network servers for video data storage for access control and surveillance applications, for alarm monitoring applications, and for security applications; computer software and hardware for controlling and operating security and access system comprising locks, doors, and access and identification; electronic machines and apparatus for securing keys; electric and electronic video surveillance equipment sold individually as components or together as a system comprising one or more surveillance cameras, covert cameras, close circuit television cameras, camera housings, camera mounts, camera lenses, video monitors, video recorders, digital video recorders, video storage media, video switches, control panels, keypad controllers, computer joystick controllers, transceivers, receivers, transmitters, signal processors, multiplexers, matrix switches, power controllers, control panel housing, switch housing, transformer switches, splitters, coaxial cables, connectors, motion detectors, microphones, and speakers; computer user interface software and control software for managing security, fire, and access systems; hand-held electronic computer and communication hardware for receiving, controlling, storing, manipulating, displaying and transmitting data for operating electronic locks; cards encoded with security features for identification purposes; radio-frequency identification (RFID) tags; data processing software and computer hardware; siren speakers and electronic siren drivers, namely, tone generators and amplifiers adapted to be used for sirens; switch units incorporating magnetically actuated reed switches for use in burglary and fire sensing alarm systems, in industrial position sensing apparatus, in revolution counters, in equipment cabinet safety interlock systems, in industrial position controlling apparatus, in electrical cables and in pump and valve controlling apparatus and in home security alarm systems; time or condition sensing apparatus for initiating and controlling regeneration or backwash cycles for water treatment equipment; bioreactors for culturing cells; portable analytical instruments, namely, probes with a microprocessor based data conversion logger for measurement of organic and inorganic chemicals in water; filters and filter housings for laboratory use; fluid separation apparatus for laboratory use; membrane filters for laboratory use; silt density measuring device; deionization units for laboratory use; fluid flow control devices, namely, pumps, valves, flow meters, and regulators for laboratory use; ozone monitors; laboratory equipment, namely, porous microtiter plates for use in cell biology and other life science applications; electronic water and process treatment controls, namely, apparatus for use in the treatment of commercial and industrial water systems, boiler water systems, cooling water systems, closed water systems, fuel processing systems, and metal processing systems to analyze the chemistry of the system, determine the proper treatment program, apply the desired treatment, and monitor the effectiveness of the treatment; computer software for data management in the water treatment field; electronic controllers used for processing information in the water treatment field; electronic machines and apparatus for use in industrial water systems to measure and control ph and conductivity; electronic apparatus for feeding chemicals to an industrial, commercial, or municipal water system in measured amounts; laboratory testing equipment, namely, deposition and corrosion rate testers; laboratory apparatus and instruments equipped with equipment and instrumentation to monitor and measure ph, conductivity, and chromatic concentration of industrial and domestic waters, to conduct inorganic and microbiological analysis of water; avionic sensor systems, namely, navigation systems; battery chargers; computer hardware and software for use with medical patient monitoring equipment, and for receiving, processing, transmitting and displaying data; computer software for accessing information directories that may be downloaded from the global computer network; computer software for controlling and managing patient medical information; electric control devices for heating and energy management; electrical apparatus, namely, charging stations for charging electric vehicles; transmitters of electronic signals, remote control apparatus, computers and computer software used in the railway industry for detecting and controlling trains, ground faults, broken rails, power failures, track switches and lights; electronic sensors for monitoring energy utilization, temperature, position, distance, speed, and acceleration; electrical substations comprised of transformers, circuit breakers, circuit switchers, voltage regulators, fuses, capacitors, relays, rectifiers, and electric power converters; power inverters; electronic control devices for energy management; electronic automation products, namely, electrical routers and electrical hubs; computer software and hardware for the management, distribution, monitoring, and control of energy; automation systems, namely, computer software and hardware and communications devices for planning, scheduling, controlling, monitoring, and providing information on transportation assets and parts thereof; automation systems, namely, computer hardware for embedded operating systems and pc based computer software, for monitoring specified conditions and controlling respective innovative devices within a designated area; computer hardware and software systems for automated train control and traffic supervision, namely, location tracking, vehicle monitoring, vehicle controlling, dispatching, signaling, communication, and data transmission; computer software for management of railway networks; wireless communication devices for voice, data, or image transmission; traffic management equipment, namely, display monitors, computers, auto compasses, and software to manage traffic; computer software for interfacing and interacting with remote control locomotives and locomotive hardware; led traffic and rail signals; electronic fuel level gauges; computer operating software and electric control panels for automated fuel station management systems; gas meters; electrical and scientific apparatus, namely, general-purpose high-precision electric computer-controlled valves for use in high-precision flow applications; optical apparatus and instruments; apparatus for displaying images; microscopes; automated dna optical scanners; automated microscopy systems comprising microscopes, computer hardware, and software; electromechanical hardware and software systems comprising of computers, computer software, electromechanical positioners for micro-positioning control, all for use in the field of photonics, digital flow control, analysis of biological samples, semiconductor testing and inspection, microscopy, optical scanning, and in the field of scanning systems for lasers; computer software for microscopy, imaging, and informatics in the field of clinical and diagnostic testing; electric actuators; electric valve actuators; precision positioning systems comprised of optical indexers, namely, an optical train with a camera and a filter wheel that enables image data to be digitized, microscopy stages, electronic control circuitry, motion detectors, and tunable lasers for digitizing images in the fields of photonics, bio-medical imaging, fluidics, mass flow valves, life sciences, semiconductor manufacturing, and clinical diagnostics; modular biologics manufacturing system used for growing, purifying, concentrating, isolating, and packaging biological materials in chemical, of a bioreactor used to grow cell cultures and biological products, a separation machine used for isolating, purifying, and concentrating biological materials, and connecting computer hardware and software; computer hardware and software for use in industrial processing plants and refineries in the chemical, petrochemical, and processing industries.」

(長文のため、ここでは本文の冒頭のみを掲載しています。全文はこのページの表示後に読み込まれます。)

出典:特許庁「審決公報」(令和8年5月29日発行・号数2026-005、公報発行サイト https://www.gazette.jpo.go.jp/scciidl010 )を加工して作成(加工:TaiLexi AI)
本文は公表資料(PDF 等)から機械的に抽出・整形したもので、改行や記号に誤りを含むことがあります。正確な文言は原本でご確認ください。